Briefly Noted: ‘The White House Boys’ and ‘The Boys in the Dark’ (updated 09/21/2014)

Standard

The dorms make the school look like a college.

Updates are collected at the end of the post. As you’ll see, the updates focus on the school rather than on the books.

A writer friend of mine in Florida who knows I’ve been working on a series of short stories set in the Florida Panhandle, sent me this link as an idea for a story: Mystery surrounds graves at boys’ reform school. Here’s how it begins: This Florida panhandle town is the home of a mystery that has been lost to time.  A small cemetery buried deep into the grounds of a now-defunct boys reform school dates back to the early 1900s. Rusting white steel crosses mark the graves of 31 unidentified former students. (See updates at the end of this post.)

When I read the story, I didn’t initially recognize the school because its most recent name, Arthur G Dozier School for Boys, didn’t connect in my brain with the name, Florida Industrial School for Boys, used for the Marianna, Florida reform school when I was living in Florida in the 1950s and 1960s. The Florida Department of Juvenile Justice operated the school between 1900 to 2011.

Several facts became clear as I read the story and then followed links and Google searches to other stories. The use of the word “school” to describe a physical plant that looked Edenic but which contained unidentified graves of former “students” was misleading to the general public, including those of us who lived in the state capital 85 miles away who had no clue that some of the authorities there based their approach to “reform” on the worst techniques for the control of “undesirables” coming out of World War II POW camps.

The White House

The ugly truth

Connecting the dots, the boys’ “progress” in the school included a small white house where the rapes, beatings and other horrors occurred after which possibly some of them were buried in the unmarked graves now being investigated. Logically, this is unlikely because, as local historian Dale Cox notes, why would the state murder a student and then mark and maintain his grave? Others contend the graves are for those who died in an influenza outbreak and a fire.

Fortunately, most of the men survived; unfortunately, they have enough haunting memories to last a lifetime.

Some 300 of these survivors have formed an organization called The White House Boys. On their website, you will find news about recent press reports, stories contributed by those who are just now coming forward to tell the world what was happening in Marianna, and links to recent press reports about the State of Florida’s investigation that began several years ago.

I got through high school without any brushes with school authorities or police. Some of those who had problems, many of them trivial, were packed off to reform school. I don’t know if any of the White House Boys were in school with me at Tallahassee’s Leon High School. I haven’t yet seen any names I know. The “problem” students just went away: expelled, dropped out, or joined the service. If they caught the State’s attention through what (for them) was called “the justice system,” news stories in the local paper often said they were being sent to “reform school.”

The old secret.

Then, I had no concept what was supposed to happen at a reform school. Remedial classes? Encounter groups? Campfire sings? Rape and beatings never crossed my mind as mainstays of the curriculum. Right now, I’m too angry about it to remotely consider writing fiction.

I’m angry because it happened in a nearby town I visited often (due to the Florida Caverns State Park there), and I’m angry that it happened right under the noses of state lawmakers and they were either blind or indifferent to it, and I’m angry that even now the story about the investigation, the abuses and the graves has been going on across the border in Florida and I heard nothing about it until my friend sent me that link.

If you want to learn more, and you really don’t even though you must, click on the White House Boys link and/or do a Google search and you will find more than you can bear to know.

The Books

Two books are among those spelling out the details: The White House Boys and The Boys in the Dark.

The White House Boys: An American Tragedy, by Roger Dean Kiser, publisher’s description:

Hidden far from sight, deep in the thick underbrush of the North Florida woods are the ghostly graves of more than thirty unidentified bodies, some of which are thought to be children who were beaten to death at the old Florida Industrial School for Boys at Marianna. It is suspected that many more bodies will be found in the fields and swamplands surrounding the institution. Investigations into the unmarked graves have compelled many grown men to come forward and share their stories of the abuses they endured and the atrocities they witnessed in the 1950s and 1960s at the institution.

The White House Boys: An American Tragedy is the true story of the horrors recalled by Roger Dean Kiser, one of the boys incarcerated at the facility in the late fifties for the crime of being a confused, unwanted, and wayward child. In a style reminiscent of the works of Mark Twain, Kiser recollects the horrifying verbal, sexual, and physical abuse he and other innocent young boys endured at the hands of their “caretakers.” Questions remain unanswered and theories abound, but Roger and the other ‘White House Boys’ are determined to learn the truth and see justice served.

-

The Boys of the Dark: A Story of Betrayal and Redemption in the Deep South, by Robin Gaby Fisher, Michael O’McCarthy, and Robert W. Straley, publisher’s description:

A story that garnered national attention, this is the harrowing tale of two men who suffered abuses at a reform school in Florida in the 1950s and 60s, and who banded together fifty years later to confront their attackers.

Michael O’McCarthy and Robert W. Straley were teens when they were termed “incorrigible youth” by authorities and ordered to attend the Florida School for Boys. They discovered in Marianna, the “City of Southern Charm,” an immaculately groomed campus that looked more like an idyllic university than a reform school. But hidden behind the gates of the Florida School for Boys was a hell unlike any they could have imagined. The school’s guards and administrators acted as their jailers and tormentors. The boys allegedly bore witness to assault, rape, and possibly even murder.

For fifty years, both men—and countless others like them—carried their torment in silence. But a series of unlikely events brought O’McCarthy, now a successful rights activist, and Straley together, and they became determined to expose the Florida School for Boys for what they believed it to be: a youth prison with a century-long history of abuse. They embarked upon a campaign that would change their lives and inspire others.

Robin Gaby Fisher, a Pulitzer Prize–winning journalist and author of the New York Times bestselling After the Fire, collaborates with Straley and O’McCarthy to offer a riveting account of their harrowing ordeal. The book goes beyond the story of the two men to expose the truth about a century-old institution and a town that adopted a Nuremberg-like code of secrecy and a government that failed to address its own wrongdoing. What emerges is a tale of strength, resolve, and vindication in the face of the kinds of terror few can imagine.

I thank my friend for sending me the link. I don’t have the knowledge to turn this into a gripping novel. But then, I don’t need to, for those who were there are already telling their stories. I can’t so better. I wouldn’t presume to try.

UPDATE:  From NBC news on December 11, 2012: Abuses at infamous Florida boys reform school even more widespread, report says – “Scientists have found 19 previously unknown grave shafts on the grounds of a notorious Florida reform school, suggesting that many more boys died there amid brutal conditions than had previously been known”

UPDATE: From “The Guardian” on August 7, 2013: Florida to exhume remains found at notorious Dozier School for Boys – “Governor Rick Scott and the rest of Florida’s cabinet voted unanimously on Tuesday to allow dozens of unmarked graves found in woods near the school to be opened up. The decision comes after a team of researchers found evidence of almost 100 deaths at the institution.”

UPDATE: (January 28, 2014): Remains of 55 bodies found near former Florida reform school - “Excavations at a makeshift graveyard near a now-closed reform school in the Florida Panhandle have yielded remains of 55 bodies, almost twice the number official records say are there.”

UPDATE: (August 8, 2014): Boy missing since 1940 ID’d at shuttered Florida boys school – “(CNN) — On their deathbeds — her father’s in the 1960s and her mother’s in the 1980s — Ovell Krell’s parents made her promise she’d never stop looking for her brother.” Joseph Johnson, Former ‘White House Boy’ from Knoxville confronts his past and recalls horrors of Florida reform published in Knoxville on August 31 and updated on September 11.

UPDATE: (September 21, 2014) Sister reveals story about brother sentenced to Dozier school – Havana Herald article about the circumstances of George Owen Smith.

Malcolm

19 responses

  1. It’s amazing, the horrific stories we can find that occurred here in “The land of the free and the home of the brave,” if we just dig a little. Don’t even have to dig too deeply. Stories like these make me wonder how people can think the human race is above the animals. These stories prove we are, after all, just another species of animal–and in my opinion, not a very evolved one. This could make the background for a great short story, though, I agree.

    • Actually, the beatings in the Okeechobee boys’ school were as bad and worse than those in Marianna. I notice they don’t mention the other school. What they tell you is true. I was in both schools, and spent 70-days witnessing floggings and counting lashes. They did in fact beat children to bloody pulp repeatedly over a very long time, many years. They liked doing it.

      9-11 Sic semper tyrannis.

      • I think one of the news stories about the investigation might have mentioned Okeechobee. I hope the State of Florida can get to the bottom of this, because it’s damned horrible. I’m glad the books are helping to spread the word. I’m glad you found this post and added a comment. I grew up in Tallahassee and didn’t hear one thing about any of this back in the 1960s ande 1970s before I moved away. Now people are learning the truth.

        Malcolm

        • Hello Everyone: I did get another comment about this post that contained interesting information. I have elected not to display it because it mentioned an individual by name and stated that he was guilty of a crime. To display that quote would be to publish libelous material and I don’t think any of us want to get sued.

          Malcolm

  2. When I stumbled across the article I had no idea of the true horror behind the headline. This is absolutely sickening! Kudos to the brave survivors for coming forward and speaking out. I feel compelled to look up those two books, even though I’m afraid of what I’ll learn.

  3. How incredibly sad and disgusting! Until the past several years when things like this have really begun to come out I just didn’t believe that there were so many who have not deserved to be members of our species.

  4. When I was a kid, I never would have believed a story like this; it was happening down the road from me while I was in high school, and I’m not sure I would have believed it then. Now, I have to believe it, and that’s a damn shame.

    Malcolm

    • I am completely lacking in the ability to understand actions like those. Can hardly bring myself to believe them. And today similar things that happened with the Boy Scouts are in the news again. There is good, and there is much evil. Thank God I know at least some of the good people!

      • Yes, I’ve been seeing those stories about the Scouts; as a Eagle Scout, I don’t want to believe those either. Like you, I know good people and have known other good people in the past. Thinking on that helps sustain me when I see more evidence of the bad humans can do.

        Malcolm

  5. Pingback: BOOK BITS: Amazon in Brazil, ‘Lighthouse Road,’ Jami Attenberg, Sister Spot, Weird comments in bookstores « The Sun Singer's Travels

  6. Pingback: Thank you for the 14,000 views in 2012 « Malcolm's Round Table

      • The horrific beatings happened. There is absolutely no question whatsoever about the beatings. As for the rapes and the murders, I know nothing. I did not see any sex play or rapes. I did not see anyone killed; however, one other fellow and I might possibly know of a black kid they beat to death or nearly to death. I was there during his torture sessions. It is hard to believe anybody could have survived what they did to him. Malcolm.You are right. You would never have believed such stories when you were young. I know because I told people accurately abou what was going on in Okeechobee in 1965, and everybody responded with incredulity. They said nobody could do that and get away with it.

  7. Understandably, this remains a volatile issue for those directly and indirectly involved, I appreciate the comments. But, due to libel laws, I can’t post any comment here that name an individual and suggest s/he is guilty of a crime unless that person has been charged, tried and found guilty AND the crime is also relevant to the initial post about the books.

    Malcolm